Utah Case: Are Violent Video Games Probable Cause for Arrest?
Posted on Jan 05, 2008 under Main |
Kiddus Chane Yohannes played violent video games and owned some guns.
Those facts, coupled with comments Yohannes allegedly made about killing people, were enough to get him arrested by police in Orem, Utah. As reported by the Deseret News, however, a judge dismissed most of the counts against the 20-year-old Ethiopian man, a student at Utah Valley State College.
Police had charged him with using false identification numbers to purchase the guns, but Judge Gary Stott determined that the facts of the case did not support the charge. A count for possessing a stolen ATM card was held for trial.
Yohannes’ attorney, Richard Gale, commented:
In our zeal to be protected from other people, we can’t start arresting people and charging them with crimes they haven’t committed yet, which we suspect they’re going to commit in the future.
Prosecutor Donna Kelly told the newspaper:
The police began very concerned about [Yohannes] when the roommates were saying … that he was hiding weapons and that he was playing violent games and discussing that he was going to kill people. Those were the things that caused the police to look a little harder into how he obtained the weapons.
Yohannes’ attorney credited the police with trying to do the right thing:
[Yohannes] had a roommate that was scared and told the police. I think (police) had good intentions, they want to make sure that a school shooting doesn’t happen here, but they went about it in the wrong way by trying to look for a criminal charge instead of getting him into counseling. I know people don’t like to hear that, they want law enforcement to stop these kinds of shootings before they happen — (but) we cannot stop people for doing things that we think they’re going to do in the future.
GP: The threats allegedly made by Yohannes aren’t described in the news article, although we can assume they were detailed enough to legitimately concern not only the roommate but the Orem P.D. as well. Coupled with Yohannes’ gun ownership, it’s hard to fault the police for at least looking into the matter.
What is troubling about the case, however, is that Yohannes’ violent video game playing was apparently included as an element of probable cause in the investigation. Guns, threats and video games are what got him arrested. It’s not clear what games Yohannes played, but a follow-up article in the Deseret News reports that:
[Yohannes was] playing video games depicting violence to U.S. soldiers and police officers.
That description suits a number of commercially available games issued by major game publishers, including the Grand Theft Auto series, 25 to Life (which was quite controversial in Utah) and Battlefield 2.
We should note that police in Utah were probably on high alert at the time of Yohannes’ arrest. Yohannes was a student and his arrest took place within two months of Virginia Tech. As GamePolitics readers know, video games were incorrectly suggested as a causal factor in that massacre.
And just a few months earlier, another young immigrant, Sulejman Talovic, killed several people in a shooting rampage at a mall in Salt Lake City. Police investigators found no evidence that Talovic played violent games in that case, although the possibility was suggested and even discussed by Utah legislators while the investigation was underway.
So, going forward, does this mean that playing Halo 3 or Manhunt 2 makes one more likely to face police inquiries? Should one’s choice of games be given consideration by authorities in criminal investigations?
This entry was posted on Friday, January 4th, 2008 at 8:10 am and is filed under Controversial Games, Court Cases, First Amendment, Games & the Law. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
| Digg it | Slashdot
Source: Utah Case: Are Violent Video Games Probable Cause for Arrest?
utah uutah uttah utaah utahh utah case ccase caase casse casee case are aare arre aree are violent vviolent viiolent vioolent viollent violeent violennt violentt violent video vvideo viideo viddeo videeo videoo video games ggames gaames gammes gamees gamess games probable pprobable prrobable proobable probbable probaable probabble probablle probablee probable cause ccause caause cauuse causse causee cause for ffor foor forr for arrest aarrest arrrest arrrest arreest arresst arrestt arrest utah tah uah uth uta utah case ase cse cae cas case are re ae ar are violent iolent volent vilent vioent violnt violet violen violent video ideo vdeo vieo vido vide video games ames gmes gaes gams game games probable robable pobable prbable proable probble probale probabe probabl probable cause ause cuse case caue caus cause for or fr fo for arrest rrest arest arest arrst arret arres arrest utah u tah ut ah uta h utah utah case c ase ca se cas e case case are a re ar e are are violent v iolent vi olent vio lent viol ent viole nt violen t violent violent video v ideo vi deo vid eo vide o video video games g ames ga mes gam es game s games games probable p robable pr obable pro bable prob able proba ble probab le probabl e probable probable cause c ause ca use cau se caus e cause cause for f or fo r for for arrest a rrest ar rest arr est arre st arres t arrest arrest utah tuah uath utha utah utah case acse csae caes case case are rae aer are are violent ivolent voilent viloent vioelnt violnet violetn violent violent video ivdeo vdieo viedo vidoe video video games agmes gmaes gaems gamse games games probable rpobable porbable prboable proabble probbale probalbe probabel probable probable cause acuse cuase casue caues cause cause for ofr fro for for arrest rarest arrest arerst arrset arrets arrest arrest ytah itah xase vase sre ciolent biolent cideo bideo fames hames orobable xause vause dor gor srrest jutah owtah ytah udah utaih uteih uteh utoh utuh utih ckase tase kase sase zase qase caise ceise cese cose cuse cise cace caze casi casee casae casea casa aire eire ere ore ure ire aer ari aree arae area ara fiolent ffiolent wiolent veolent vieolent veeolent vaolent veaolent vyolent viughlent vialent violint violeent violaent violeant violant violeknt violend fideo ffideo wideo vedeo viedeo veedeo vadeo veadeo vydeo viteo vidio videeo vidaeo videao vidao videugh videa james gaimes geimes gemes gomes gumes gimes gamis gamees gamaes gameas gamas gamz gamec gamez brobable prughbable prabable propable probaible probeible probeble proboble probuble probible probaple probabli probablee probablae probablea probabla ckause tause kause sause zause qause caiuse ceiuse ceuse couse cuuse ciuse couse cajuse caowse cayse cauce cauze causi causee causae causea causa phor vor fughr far airrest eirrest errest orrest urrest irrest arerst arrist arreest arraest arreast arrast arrzt arrect arrezt arresd
